Question What is the evidence for following the Prophet (blessings and peace of Allah be upon him) in his actions, especially since there is a difference of opinion concerning the principle that what matters is the general meaning (not the specific reason for a particular teaching). Is the general principle …
Read More »What should one do when there is a conflict between shar‘i texts?
Question How can we understand the argument that says that shar‘i rules and regulations came one after another? For example, there may be a hadeeth that makes something obligatory, then we find another hadeeth on the same issue that does not make it obligatory. Some scholars have suggested the following: …
Read More »Acceptance of da‘eef hadiths as evidence by the Hanbalis and others
Question Some people claim that the Hanbali madhhab is quite lax and easygoing in its acceptance of hadeeth and therefore follows a lot of weak hadeeth. What do you have to say about this. Answer Praise be to Allah. The view of Imam Ahmad regarding what may be accepted …
Read More »Response to those who say: I refer directly to the Qur’an and Sunnah, with no need for scholars
Question How should I respond to what some of my relatives say? When I tell them about the views of the scholars which explain to them that some of the things they do are haram, with evidence, they say: We learn our religion directly from the Qur’an and Sunnah, with …
Read More »